Baby Crib and Toddler Mattresses
Colgate is legendary for our commitment to exacting manufacturing standards of crafting safe crib and toddler mattresses. We use only the highest quality components, hand assembled right here in the USA because while many crib mattresses may look similar on the outside, we know it’s what’s on the inside that counts. Feel free to contact us directly for any advice, we’re here to help.
Retro Posh
Retro Posh
$ 219.99
Quick Shop
EverTrue™ Cuddle (Squiggles)
EverTrue™ Cuddle (Squiggles)
$ 329.99
Quick Shop
2-N-1 Mattress Crib Mattress
2-N-1 Mattress Crib Mattress
$ 179.99
Quick Shop

Eco Foam Supreme Crib Mattress
Eco Foam Supreme Crib Mattress
$ 129.99
Quick Shop
Eco Classica I Crib Mattress
Eco Classica I Crib Mattress
$ 189.99
Quick Shop
Eco Classica I with Organic Cotton Cover Crib Mattress
Eco Classica I with Organic Cotton Cover Crib Mattress
$ 187.99
Quick Shop

Eco Classica III Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress
Eco Classica III Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress
$ 229.99
Quick Shop
Classica III
Classica III
$ 159.99
Quick Shop
Colgate Classica I Crib Mattress
Colgate Classica I Crib Mattress
$ 149.99
Quick Shop

Ultra II Crib Mattress
Ultra II Crib Mattress
$ 169.99
Quick Shop
EverTrue Diamond Crib Mattress
EverTrue Diamond Crib Mattress
$ 384.99
Quick Shop
EverTrue™ Elite Crib Mattress
EverTrue™ Elite Crib Mattress
$ 309.99
Quick Shop

EverTrue™ Grand Crib Mattress
EverTrue™ Grand Crib Mattress
$ 274.99
Quick Shop
Natural I Crib Mattress
Natural I Crib Mattress
$ 374.99
Quick Shop
Nuzzle Snuze™ Chick-A-Dee  Chick-A-Dee Crib Mattress
Nuzzle Snuze™ Chick-A-Dee Chick-A-Dee Crib Mattress
$ 299.98
Quick Shop

Night Night
Night Night
IN-STORE
Quick Shop
Custom-Sized Crib Mattress
Custom-Sized Crib Mattress
IN-STORE
Quick Shop
Eco Spring Ultra II Crib Mattress
Eco Spring Ultra II Crib Mattress
$ 229.99
Quick Shop

Monarch 2-Stage Innerspring Mattress
Monarch 2-Stage Innerspring Mattress
IN-STORE
Quick Shop
Regal II Deluxe
Regal II Deluxe
IN-STORE
Quick Shop
EverTrue™ Hush Crib Mattress
EverTrue™ Hush Crib Mattress
$ 192.99
Quick Shop

EverTrue™ Serene Crib Mattress
EverTrue™ Serene Crib Mattress
$ 209.99
Quick Shop
Eco Visco Classica Crib Mattress
Eco Visco Classica Crib Mattress
$ 309.99
Quick Shop
Colgate Eco Spring 2-N-1 - Organic Cotton Cover
Colgate Eco Spring 2-N-1 - Organic Cotton Cover
$ 299.99
Quick Shop

Nuzzle Snuze™ Squiggles Crib Mattress
Nuzzle Snuze™ Squiggles Crib Mattress
$ 299.98
Quick Shop
Visco Classica II
Visco Classica II
IN-STORE
Quick Shop
breathe-flex™
breathe-flex™
IN-STORE
Quick Shop

Visco Classica
Visco Classica
$ 249.99
Quick Shop
Little Aristocrat I Crib Mattress
Little Aristocrat I Crib Mattress
$ 132.99
Quick Shop
EverTrue™ Cuddle (Dottie Lottie)
EverTrue™ Cuddle (Dottie Lottie)
$ 329.99
Quick Shop

EverTrue™ Cuddle (Chick-A-Dee)
EverTrue™ Cuddle (Chick-A-Dee)
$ 329.99
Quick Shop
Nuzzle Snuze™ Dottie Lottie Crib Mattress
Nuzzle Snuze™ Dottie Lottie Crib Mattress
$ 299.98
Quick Shop